165,000 New Jobs, But Full-Time Work Is Still Shrinking
October payrolls beat every forecast at 165,000, but full-time employment sits at 49.0% of the working-age population, below 2019's 50.6% — and productivity, not hiring, is carrying profits.

S&P 500 companies are on track to report 31.4% earnings growth for the third quarter — the eighth straight quarter of double-digit gains — yet fewer Americans hold full-time jobs today than in September 2025. That's the puzzle Lance Roberts, managing partner at RIA Advisors in Houston, lays out in his latest macro analysis for Real Investment Advice: the headline numbers say boom, the composition of employment says something else.
What did the October jobs report actually show?
Payrolls beat every forecast at 165,000, according to the October jobs report released last Friday. On its face, that's strength. Dig one layer down and the picture gets softer.
Full-time employment now stands at 49.0% of the working-age population, well below its 2019 level of 50.6%. So the economy is adding jobs. It isn't adding the kind of jobs that anchor household balance sheets. That gap — 1.6 percentage points of the working-age population — is the difference between a tight labor market and one that merely looks tight in the payroll count.
Why are profits rising without hiring?
Roberts' core argument is labor hoarding: firms hold onto workers rather than rehire later, which suppresses layoffs and jobless claims even when demand softens. The data backs him up.
- Output rose 3.7% last quarter.
- Hours worked rose just 0.1%.
- Productivity, not headcount, is carrying profits.
That combination explains how earnings can grow 31.4% while full-time employment shrinks. Companies are extracting more from the workers they already have. For an individual job seeker, that means hiring managers have little pressure to post new roles — the output is coming from within.
What do the wage and part-time numbers signal?
Involuntary part-time work (people who want full-time hours but can't get them) jumped 339,000 in October to 4.8 million. That's a big one-month move. It suggests employers are cutting hours before they cut heads, the classic first step in a slowdown that the headline payroll number won't show.
Pay growth tells the same story from the other side. Wages rose 3.1%, still trailing inflation at 3.7%. In real terms, the average worker's paycheck buys less than it did a year ago. Earnings growth at the corporate level isn't flowing through to compensation.
Which recession indicators should you trust?
Here's the sharp edge of Roberts' analysis: the recession indicators flashing green — initial claims and announced layoffs — are precisely the ones labor hoarding suppresses the longest. When firms stockpile workers instead of cutting them, the traditional early-warning signals stay quiet well past the point where underlying demand has weakened. The 165,000 payroll beat and the green claims data may measure the same distortion, not genuine strength.
For practitioners reading the tape: treat claims and layoff counts as lagging signals in this cycle, and watch full-time employment share and involuntary part-time work as the leading ones. The 49.0% figure against 50.6% in 2019 is your benchmark.
Roberts closes on the implication investors face: if productivity-driven earnings growth has limits, and hours can't be cut forever, the gap between 31.4% profit growth and a shrinking full-time workforce will eventually force a resolution in one direction or the other.
Source: seekingalpha.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.
569 articles
Go deeper
- U.S. Payrolls Grew by 90,000, Beating Forecasts
- US Private Employers Added 86,000 Jobs, Beating Forecasts
- U.S. Job Growth Slows to 29,000 in September, Missing Forecasts
- Long-Term Unemployment Hits Highest Share Since 1950 as Workers Stay Put
- US Economy Added 165,000 Jobs in October, Cutting Jobless Rate to 4.1%