Hiring Trends

270 Applicants Per Job: Fraud Reshapes the Hiring Screen

Greenhouse roles now average 270 applicants, up from 116 in 2022, while fraud rates hit 10-15 percent in gig roles — and screening vendors are racing to fix what resumes no longer prove.

Screening Is Having Its Moment, and Fraud Is the Reason
Screening Is Having Its Moment, and Fraud Is the Reason — Markus Winkler / unsplash

The average open role on Greenhouse now draws 270 applicants, up from 116 in 2022 — a 133 percent jump in two years, while recruiting teams shrank by more than half. CEO Daniel Chait gave Forbes the figures last month, and they explain why screening has suddenly become the hottest corner of recruiting technology. Fraud is the reason.

The application itself has stopped being a reliable signal. As Findem co-founder Hari Kolam put it: "The volume of applicants and the [surface] quality of applicants essentially increases because generating English has become a commodity." Resumes are now written by AI, tailored by AI, and often submitted by AI on behalf of someone who may not exist. Every screening vendor at last month's HR Tech conference agreed the application document no longer carries the information recruiters need. They split on where trustworthy information should come from instead.

What does this mean for candidates right now?

One camp wants more evidence about you, from external sources. Yardstik, which closed a $30 million Series B in September, starts at the background check — and argues the check was never really checking. CEO Andrew Johnson describes the traditional process: it gathers your information at the point of hire, never verifies that the Social Security number belongs to the person typing it, and never looks again. "You're just assumed good forever." Yardstik matches a driver's license to a face and the face to the Social Security number first, then reads device and network signals — an email address created last week, or an application for a Minnesota job sent from a phone in the Dominican Republic. One in ten applicants it now sees has already been verified once. In gig and remote roles the company sees fraud rates of 10 to 15 percent, including one early customer that found a ring selling stolen Social Security numbers to people who used them to clear screening.

Findem applies the same logic to the resume. On October 20 it launched Authenticity Suite Pro, built on Glider, the assessment and proctoring company acquired this spring. It checks claims against a database of patents, licenses and company histories, flagging conflicting employment dates, nonexistent companies, or repeated applications from one location. Flagged candidates get a proctored verification session with a liveness check and government ID, and the recruiter receives a plain-language report: successful, unsuccessful or inconclusive.

Fama looks in a third place — what you have already said in public. Its October product, Lens, starts from a written policy and screens social media against it, with every decision traced to a specific policy element. CEO Ben Mones shared a real example: a social media company screening influencers for under-21 campaigns flagged an ice cream cake, because the agent looked up the recipe and found rum.

Will you interview with AI?

The other camp has stopped looking for evidence and started asking candidates to produce it. Greenhouse acquired Ezra, a voice AI interviewer, roughly six months ago, announcing the deal at the last ERE Recruiting Innovation Summit. Founder Ophir Samson, now head of voice AI at Greenhouse, knows the reputation problem. "The conversation right now on Reddit and LinkedIn threads is: this is bad," he said — adding that with the same information, he would feel the same way. His framing of the real choice: a written application vanishing into a black hole alongside a thousand others, most of them bots, versus a 10-to-15-minute conversation where you answer aloud, in real time, and can ask questions back. "You don't have to guess what they're interested in. They're asking you," Samson said.

XLOT, a two-person startup from Munich, pushes the effort idea furthest. Instead of a work test, it drops candidates into a simulated first week: one task, incomplete information, a simulated manager and peers to question. Its October patent filing covers the mechanism — information appears only when the candidate asks. The platform scores the solution, the reasoning, the questions asked, and the questions not asked. Co-founder Ilya Billig sees effort as the filter: candidates will do the quest only for jobs they genuinely want, and companies "will get a short list of motivated candidates that demonstrated that they have the right skills."

Whichever camp wins, survivors reach a human interview that is also changing. Katherine Loranger, chief people officer at Safeguard Global, is retraining managers to probe reasoning rather than history: "It's not going to be about learning what they did, but learning why they did it, what they were thinking, how they would do things differently, and what they've learned." It makes candidates uncomfortable, she acknowledged — "But that's where we figure out where they are." As application volumes keep climbing, expect screening to stay at the center of recruiting budgets through 2025.

Original: ererecruitingconference.com

applicant-fraudcandidate-screeningai-generated-resumesrecruiting-technologyvoice-ai-interviews

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

606 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »