Handshake AI Owes Contractors $64,000 in Disputes, Workers Say
Nearly two dozen contractors say Handshake AI underpaid them by hundreds or thousands each. One student logged $19,000 and got $8,000.

Contractors have filed pay disputes totaling $64,000 against Handshake AI over the past six months, according to nearly two dozen current and former workers who spoke to Business Insider. The AI-training arm of career-app startup Handshake recruited them with rates of $50 an hour or more. Many now say they were underpaid by hundreds or thousands of dollars each.
One of them is Joel Thomas, a junior at the University of Mary Washington. He says Handshake owes him about $11,000 in back pay. His dashboard once showed earnings above $19,000. He received $8,000. In short: the pay he could see and the pay he got were two different numbers.
What went wrong with the pay?
Business Insider reviewed bank statements, pay stubs, and hundreds of emails and Slack messages. It found several causes. Handshake paid contractors in units like dollars per hour or dollars per task, but the dashboards showed estimates based on manually logged timers. The client — the AI company funding the project — ran a second, invisible timer. Handshake compared the two before paying, and contractors didn't know what counted as billable time.
Review rejections cost money too. If a contractor misread confusing or contradictory instructions and the task failed review, they weren't paid, former employees said. Project managers used AI coding tools like Claude and Lovable to generate instructions, and Slack questions piled up unanswered. On some marquee projects, one manager oversaw up to 1,000 contractors. Takeaway: the system paid for verified output, not hours worked, and workers only found out after the fact.
Handshake disputes the framing. "Final pay reflects the work our systems verify," a spokesperson said. "Where logged time doesn't match the work, we review it, and where we find inflated time we don't pay for it." The company added that "a dedicated team independent of the project reviews it in full and can restore all or part of the amount" when contractors contest decisions.
How big is this business?
Very big. Handshake says more than 188,000 contractors have earned over $500 million for AI-training work on its platform. CEO Garrett Lord said in August that the AI unit has grown past $1 billion in gross annualized revenue. Former staffers said most revenue now comes from five clients: Meta, Google, OpenAI, Nvidia, and Anthropic.
Handshake, founded in 2014 by three Michigan Tech students, started as a college career platform. Schools paid fees to connect students with employers. In January 2025 it pivoted into AI training, rebranding with AI in its name. Lord has pitched reliable pay as an edge over rivals Scale AI and Mercor. "Most AI gigs = shifting rates, zero transparency," he wrote on LinkedIn last year. "Handshake AI = competitive pay, clear expectations, and real dialogue."
What changed in October?
After BI sent detailed questions, Handshake rolled out transparency fixes in October. They include a new payments dashboard, clearer explanations for pay adjustments, an easier dispute process, and a live timer for tracking work on third-party platforms. "As part of being a Fellow you should always know what you earned, how it was calculated and when it will arrive," the company wrote in an October blog post. BI first reported contractor complaints in March, when one worker won a $6,475 small-claims judgment.
What happened to Thomas?
Thomas signed up in January after Liberty University directed him to Handshake's career fair. Spring projects paid only about $17 an hour, so he stopped. August invitations offered $50 per hour and $65 per task. He worked from roughly 9 a.m. to past midnight, including Project Folio, a ChatGPT usage study requiring him to upload past chat logs.
His payments came up short twice. Handshake told him there was "no tasking" for August 17–23 — yet a pay statement showed 428 completed tasks for Project Novel with zero pay. The company said "no tasking" means "no verified work," and it deactivated his account for irregular activity. Thomas posted on Reddit: "This is such a scum thing to do... this is ridiculous." Handshake declined to comment on his case individually.
For anyone weighing AI-training gigs, the lesson from Thomas's $11,000 gap is concrete: log your own evidence, because the platform's estimate is not a promise.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.
591 articles
Go deeper
- Doctors and Lawyers Join AI's $400-an-Hour Gig Economy
- DoorDash to Pay $132M in NYC Driver Pay Settlement as Amazon Faces New Labor Suit
- Disney Sets Aside $180M to Hire From Bankrupt Character.AI
- AI Skills Add Nearly $18,000 to Pay — But Bands Stay Frozen
- Anthropic Aims at $1.4 Trillion IPO Valuation as Claude Bills Hit Millions