Future of Work

New York Dentists Rank First for Career Security as AI Reshapes Work

Dentists top New York workers' list of careers that feel safest over the next decade, as a Careerminds survey of 3,088 workers finds hands-on trades outranking tech jobs for perceived security.

New York Workers Say Hands-On Jobs Feel Safer With AI
New York Workers Say Hands-On Jobs Feel Safer With AI — Martinelle / pixabay

Dentists in New York State rank first among all professions for feeling secure about their careers over the next decade, according to a Careerminds survey of 3,088 workers on job satisfaction and perceived security. The margin of comfort is not small, and it clusters heavily in physically skilled work.

The survey, conducted by outplacement firm Careerminds, measured workers' feelings about job security over a 10-year horizon. It does not predict which jobs AI will or will not actually replace — a distinction worth holding onto. Everything that follows describes sentiment, not forecast outcomes.

Which New York jobs feel safest?

Among New York respondents, dentists took the top spot, followed by:

  • Firefighters
  • HVAC technicians
  • Nurses
  • Electricians
  • Auto mechanics
  • Carpenters
  • Physical therapists
  • Paramedics
  • Plumbers

The pattern is consistent. Nearly every profession in the top ten involves hands-on work. AI may help workers find answers, the survey's framing concedes, but it is harder for a computer to fix an air conditioner, wire a home or care for a patient.

Who is most satisfied — and most hopeful about AI?

HVAC technicians reported the highest career satisfaction across all professions in the sample, averaging 7.5 out of 10. They were also the most optimistic about AI itself. More than half said AI could make their work better over the next 10 years.

That pairing matters. The workers who feel safest are not uniformly hostile to the technology; many expect it to assist rather than displace them. The survey does not specify how, and that gap between expectation and mechanism remains untested.

Electrician or software developer?

Careerminds asked workers which career they would choose for their own child: electrician or software developer. Over 60% chose electrician. Only 38% chose software developer.

The result cuts against two decades of conventional career advice that treated learning to code as one of the safest paths available. Parents and workers in this sample appear to have repriced that assumption against AI's rapid advance in exactly the field once considered automation-proof.

What would workers give up for security?

Security is not an abstraction for these respondents. Over 40% said they would take a pay cut if it meant their job would not be replaced by AI. Read plainly: a meaningful share of the American workforce is now willing to trade income for insulation from automation — a revealed preference that no labor-market model from five years ago anticipated.

What the survey does not say

Three caveats apply. First, the sample covers 3,088 workers, and the New York figures reflect a subset of that group; Careerminds did not publish state-level sample sizes or confidence intervals. Second, the survey measures perceived security, not replacement risk, and worker sentiment has historically been a poor predictor of which roles automation actually affects. Third, no methodological detail on sampling or weighting appears in the published results, so the representativeness of the findings cannot be independently assessed.

What the data does establish is that among New York workers, the occupations judged most durable are those demanding physical presence and manual skill — and that sentiment itself has become an economic factor, one that shapes career choices, parental advice, and now, for more than 40% of workers, even the wages they will accept.

Source: 991thewhale.com

career-securityai-and-automationskilled-tradeshealthcare-careersnew-york-workforce

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

583 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »