Hiring Trends

19% of U.S. Workers Say AI Replaced Them — Then the Boss Called

19% of U.S. workers in an SHL survey say AI displaced them and their employer asked them back. For a 64-year-old on benefits, the math cuts both ways.

Nearly 1 in 5 U.S. Workers Say AI Replaced Them, Then Their Boss Asked Them Back. At 64, Returning at Higher Pay Could L
Nearly 1 in 5 U.S. Workers Say AI Replaced Them, Then Their Boss Asked Them Back. At 64, Returning at Higher Pay Could L — Md Ishak Rahman / unsplash

Nineteen percent of U.S. workers surveyed by SHL say AI replaced them — and their employers later asked them to come back. Fortune reported the figure on November 9, and it captures something genuinely new in the labor market: the boomerang rehire, at higher pay, after an AI-driven cut.

An Inc. headline on the same trend put it bluntly: companies want those workers back, and it won't be cheap. One caveat worth stating up front — the 19% covers only the people SHL surveyed, so read it as a snapshot of that group, not a national census. Even so, the pattern is real enough to plan around.

Here's the scenario that matters for anyone near retirement. Picture a 64-year-old operations manager who lost his job to an AI system last year. He claimed Social Security early to cover the gap. Now his old boss is calling him back, and the offer pays more than his old salary did. He's hypothetical, but the situation isn't unheard of. For someone already collecting benefits, taking that job cuts two ways: the paycheck can shrink his Social Security this year and grow it for life.

Why one strong year can rewrite the benefit

Social Security bases retirement benefits on a worker's highest 35 years of earnings, adjusted for wage growth. Every year, the agency rechecks the records of beneficiaries who are still working. If a new year raises the benefit, the increase is paid retroactive to the January following the year of earnings.

Higher pay only helps if it beats one of the weaker years already in the top 35. Say he earns $80,000 and that replaces an adjusted year of $30,000. Spread the $50,000 difference over the 420 months in 35 years, and his average monthly earnings rise by about $119.

The formula pays out only part of that average. If the increase falls in the 32% tier, that $119 becomes roughly $38 more per month — before accounting for his early claim, which would shrink the actual gain. Future cost-of-living adjustments would build on the higher base, and any increase would generally take effect in January 2028. It could also bolster an eligible surviving spouse's benefit.

Where the paycheck collides with the check

At 64, he hasn't reached full retirement age — 67 for anyone born in 1960 or later — so he's under the earnings test. In 2027, Social Security holds back $1 for every $2 earned above $25,560.

On an $80,000 salary, that formula calls for withholding $27,220. If his check matches the $2,170 retired-worker average after the 2027 increase, a full year of checks totals $26,040. Since withholding can't exceed what he's owed, he would receive no checks at all that year.

Those months aren't necessarily lost. At full retirement age, Social Security recalculates the benefit to credit months when payments were withheld, easing the early-claiming cut. That adjustment is separate from the wage-based increase — one reflects additional earnings, the other credits months without benefits.

Taxes and savings ripple effects

In years when salary and benefits arrive together, the IRS adds half his benefits to other income to determine taxable portion. Up to 85% of benefits he actually receives could be taxable — but if every check is withheld, there may be nothing to tax. The bigger opportunity may be savings: if the paycheck covers his bills, retirement accounts stay untouched and keep growing.

Before saying yes, he should tell Social Security his expected earnings up front to avoid an overpayment bill — the hardest mistake to undo — and pull his earnings record to find his weakest years. Each year back at work could replace one of them: a bigger paycheck now, and a slightly bigger check for life.

The SHL data suggests these rehire offers won't be rare, so workers over 62 should run their own numbers before the phone rings.

Source: 247wallst.com

ai-driven-job-replacementboomerang-rehiringsocial-securityretirement-planning

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

586 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »