Agent switching holds flat as Massachusetts 85% fee dispute advances
Only 3,390 of 113,372 agent records moved between brokerages in Q2 2026. A Massachusetts suit alleges 85% referral fees, lost CRM data and unpaid pending commissions.

By Daniel Okafor
Of 113,372 real-estate agent records across four multiple-listing-service (MLS) corridors, 3,390 changed brokerages in the second quarter of 2026, a gap of just six moves from Q2 2025, according to the Q2 2026 Agent Migration Report, published in late July by Recruiting Insight and Lone Wolf Technologies.
The figure describes four corridors rather than the entire national market, and the report does not identify destinations. “Name-brand” internal transfers, however, rose from 526 in Q4 2024 to 800 in Q2 2026, a 52% increase over 18 months.
For an agent weighing a move, the report supports a firm-by-firm comparison rather than a market-wide hiring forecast. It did not name destination brands or measure compensation, so it cannot show whether any move improved earnings.
What can a brokerage claw back?
Agents may move for better technology, educational opportunities or a culture that matches their values, the report says. Some firms use “clawbacks,” a term covering withheld percentages of pending commissions on listings nearing contract, transfer or cancellation fees when clients follow, and repayment of signing bonuses or incentives. Those terms can determine whether a move is financially viable.
What is the 85% referral-fee dispute?
The case, Lamacchia Realty v. Chinatti Realty, is pending in Massachusetts Superior Court in Middlesex County. RealTrends Verified brokerage Lamacchia Realty, eight of its agents and former sales manager Jason Posnick sued Chinatti Realty Group and broker-owner Lisa Chinatti in August 2024, amending the case in late February 2025; Inman first reported the suit.
The complaint alleges unjust enrichment—receiving a benefit without fair payment or legal basis—through Chinatti’s referral-fee practices. The plaintiffs say their independent-contractor agreements were unconscionable, or unreasonably one-sided, because former Chinatti agents faced referral fees as high as 85% when they closed transactions using leads in Chinatti’s database after joining Lamacchia.
They allege Chinatti continually claimed fees on many of their post-departure sales, preventing them from earning a living. Lamacchia says it has paid Chinatti more than $350,000 in referral fees ranging from 75% to 85% on behalf of former agents.
The agents also say they received nothing on transactions pending when they moved; Lamacchia says it paid them $113,443 to make them whole on commissions Chinatti did not pay for pending transactions that closed after their departures.
They further allege Chinatti misclassified them as independent contractors while exercising control beyond a broker’s normal supervisory duties. Lamacchia first raised the alleged conduct with Chinatti in a November 2022 letter.
What did the court find about the missing records?
During discovery last summer, Judge Lynn Rooney learned that Chinatti’s firm had moved its consumer relationship management (CRM) system from Real Geeks to Zillow’s Follow Up Boss in December 2024. Chinatti said Zillow paid a vendor to migrate the data, but the vendor found some records could not be transferred.
The court’s mid-September ruling was blunt. Judge Rooney wrote:
“I find that Lisa Chinatti knew when she received the demand letter in November 2022 that the information contained in Real Geeks was highly relevant to the plaintiffs’ causes of action. I find that Lisa Chinatti did nothing to preserve that documentation and instead, deliberately and intentionally caused the Real Geeks CRM to be destroyed.”
Rooney found unfair prejudice, meaning the evidence loss impaired the plaintiffs’ case. The missing system would likely have supported an expert review and contained each plaintiff agent’s daily work, Chinatti’s statements, and the nature of their interactions and communications, the ruling said.
If the suit reaches trial, she said jurors must receive a “very clear and forceful instruction [to the jury] that the evidence, had it been available, would have been unfavorable to the Defendants.” That is a trial-stage direction, not a final liability ruling.
The court also said agents’ CRM activity and phone conversations were monitored and recorded without call participants’ permission. Rooney forwarded the ruling and those concerns to the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Criminal Bureau for possible wiretap violations.
What happens next?
Earlier this month, the plaintiffs moved to deny summary-judgment motions—a procedural route that could end the case without a trial—that Chinatti filed since the start of the year. They argue unresolved factual disputes require a trial and requested a final pretrial conference. The court has not ruled on either side’s motions.
Chinatti did not respond to HousingWire’s request for comment on the lawsuit or ruling.
For an agent weighing a move, the Q2 figures do not remove the need to examine pending commissions, referral obligations, cancellation charges and bonus repayment in the exit agreement. The next dated tests are the court’s summary-judgment decisions and any trial schedule.
Source: housingwire.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.
569 articles