Job Market Data

Gen Z Job Seekers Underestimate Their Odds by 3 Points

Workers under 30 now understate their job-finding odds by 3 points after overstating them by 6.3 pre-2020, a New York Fed analysis of CPS and SCE data finds.

Unemployed Gen Zers don't think they can land a new job. Good news: They're wrong.
Unemployed Gen Zers don't think they can land a new job. Good news: They're wrong. — erwinbosman / pixabay

Workers under 30 who lose a job now understate their actual probability of finding a new one by 3 percentage points, a reversal from before the pandemic, when the same group overstated their job-finding odds by 6.3 points. The figures come from an analysis published on the New York Federal Reserve's Liberty Street Economics blog, which compared workers' expectations with real-world reemployment outcomes.

The study draws on two datasets: the Current Population Survey and the Survey of Consumer Expectations. It tracks newly unemployed workers — defined as people jobless and actively searching for four weeks or fewer — and measures how their expectations stack up against their actual success in landing a new role.

What changed in 2020?

Before the pandemic, Americans proved reasonably good forecasters of their own employment prospects. The expected job-finding rate and the actual job-finding rate tracked closely together, according to the authors. Workers, in effect, calibrated their job searches to real conditions.

The pandemic broke that alignment, and it has not recovered. Since 2020, workers' expectations of how easily they can find a job have diverged from reality — in one direction only. Newly unemployed Americans are now far too pessimistic about their reemployment chances, and workers under 30 account for the largest share of the gap.

The swing among younger workers is stark. Pre-pandemic, they felt overconfident, tracking above their actual results. Post-pandemic, that optimism inverted into a 3-point underestimate. The likely cause is scarring: in 2020, 25% of American workers aged 16 to 24 lost their jobs at the immediate onset of the pandemic, a disproportionate hit relative to older cohorts. Now, when Gen Z workers lose a job, they are far more likely to assume they will not find a new one — even though the data shows they generally do.

Are tenured workers also misreading the market?

Yes, in the opposite direction. The New York Fed analysis identifies a second mismatch on the job-loss side: historically, the longer a worker stays in a role, the less likely that worker is to lose it. Workers do not perceive it that way. After two years of tenure, the actual job loss rate runs at half the perceived job loss rate. People who have built up time in a position are considerably safer than they believe.

The authors do not settle on a single explanation, and the blog post itself leaves the mechanism for this perception gap open. Layoff scars are one candidate shaping how workers read their own standing. Another may be generational: millennials were more likely to face layoffs in the comedown from the post-pandemic, zero-interest-rate hiring spree, and those experiences may now inflate their sense of job-loss risk even where their positions are fairly secure.

What does this mean for an individual job search?

For an unemployed worker under 30, the practical takeaway is calibrated to the data, not to sentiment: your self-assessed odds of reemployment are, on average, too low by roughly the margin that your cohort once overstated them. For a worker with more than two years of tenure, the perceived risk of losing your job is about double the actual rate. In both cases, the gap between belief and outcome widened after 2020 and, as of the Fed's analysis, has not closed.

The Liberty Street Economics post stops short of predicting when expectations will realign with outcomes, which means the pessimism gap — not the labor market itself — is the variable worth watching.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

gen-z-workersreemployment-ratesjob-loss-riskworker-expectationsnew-york-fed

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

583 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »