Workplace Trends

AI leadership tools need manager support to deliver results

Only 37% of companies using AI leadership tools report strong results, while 64% of leaders rate combined AI and manager coaching as high-quality development.

AI leadership training tools are most effective when paired with managerial support
AI leadership training tools are most effective when paired with managerial support — StartupStockPhotos / pixabay

Tom Whitfield

Only 37% of companies using artificial intelligence (AI)-based learning tools for leadership development report strong results, according to DDI’s Global Leadership Forecast 2027; the source provides no geographic breakdown.

What do the numbers show?

DDI is a leadership development company. Nearly three-quarters of HR professionals (72%) have used or plan to use AI learning tools for leadership development, yet only 37% of companies already using them report strong results.

Because the source provides no country, regional or sector breakdown, these employer-development findings should not be read as national hiring or labor-market rates for any country.

Takeaway: Adoption is broad, but proven results remain limited.

Does AI coaching work without managers?

Among leaders who received both forms of coaching, 64% called their development “high quality,” compared with 45% receiving only manager coaching and 39% receiving only AI coaching.

DDI also found that only one in four leaders believed their manager was an effective coach. Many therefore entered development programs without the foundational skills that AI-based coaching needs to work effectively.

“Most organizations aren’t seeing strong results when using AI in development, which suggests the technology alone isn’t the answer,” said Rosey Rhyne, manager of DDI’s Center for Analytics and Behavioral Research. “The coaching that matters most comes from a leader’s manager.”

Takeaway: Manager coaching remains the essential support for effective AI-based development.

How could AI affect early-career talent?

As AI takes on tasks previously given to early-career workers, it may affect the development of critical managerial skills. In a separate study, 78% of senior HR leaders, talent-acquisition managers and learning-and-development experts said they were concerned about AI’s impact on managerial skills and the leadership pipeline.

The leadership pipeline means the pool of workers being prepared for leadership roles. For individual candidates, the risk is fewer early-career assignments through which to demonstrate judgment and build managerial skills before seeking leadership roles. Effective coaching may therefore matter more to advancement as AI changes entry-level work.

Takeaway: AI’s task shift can weaken the experience pipeline that develops future managers.

Can employers prove development works?

Employers struggle to assess organizational development programs. While 68% of HR professionals said development improves leadership capabilities, only 51% could show proof that their programs work. That gap separates participation and belief from evidence of changed leadership capabilities.

Companies that can diagnose leaders’ strengths and needs are more than twice as likely to see improved leadership capabilities, yet only 13% of HR teams use assessment extensively in this way.

The supplied source gives no sample sizes, fieldwork dates, margins of error or revision notes. It also does not identify the separate study behind the 78% finding.

Takeaway: Employers need measurable, individualized development rather than participation counts.

Does leadership development affect business performance?

Organizations with improved leadership capabilities are 1.6 times more likely to be top financial performers, according to DDI. Strong development programs can also help HR fill 39% more critical leadership roles with internal candidates, expanding the pool of workers ready to take on key positions.

“Every business strategy is a bet on leaders, but too many organizations are still making that bet without evidence,” said Verity Creedy, chief product officer at DDI.

“HR has access to something incredibly valuable: objective data about leadership capability, readiness, and growth. The opportunity now is to turn that data into intelligence the business can act on, showing not just that development happened, but where it changed leadership capability and truly strengthened the bench.”

Takeaway: Better leadership data can connect development to promotion depth and financial performance.

What should employers and workers do next?

Employers should pair AI coaching with effective manager coaching, assess leaders’ strengths and needs, personalize development and document changes in leadership capability consistently over time. Individual professionals face the same practical equation: combine technology-based learning with a manager who can identify and close skill gaps before seeking advancement.

Takeaway: The next test for employers is whether AI paired with better coaching and assessment can convert training into deeper internal promotion and stronger financial performance.

Source: hrdive.com

ai-coachingleadership-developmentmanager-coachingtalent-developmentleadership-pipeline

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

591 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »