EEOC General Counsel Nominee Evades Gender Identity Bias Questions
Catherine Eschbach, nominated as EEOC general counsel, declined to affirm protection for workers fired over gender identity at a Senate hearing Tuesday.

A 35-minute Senate confirmation hearing Tuesday left the EEOC's stance on LGBTQ+ worker protection as murky as ever, with general counsel nominee Catherine Eschbach repeatedly declining to say whether the agency should protect workers fired for gender identity or sexual orientation. For compliance teams, that ambiguity now sits at the top of the enforcement agenda.
Eschbach, appointed EEOC principal deputy general counsel in September 2025, told the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee she would build on "the important work already underway" and continue President Donald Trump's "merit-based civil rights agenda." Her stated priorities include "DEI-based discrimination," national origin discrimination against American workers, protecting women, and religious rights.
What did the nominee actually say on Title VII?
Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis., pressed directly: "Do you believe that the EEOC has a responsibility to protect workers who have been fired based on gender identity or sexual orientation?"
"I am committed to enforcing the laws that are within the EEOC's jurisdiction, consistent with their statutory authority on behalf of all American workers," Eschbach said. Asked "So that's a yes?", she repeated the same formulation.
She conceded only that the Supreme Court's Bostock v. Clayton County decision applied Title VII (the Civil Rights Act of 1964's employment provisions) to such workers "in the termination context." On whether she would bring cases covering hiring, promotions, harassment or pay discrimination based on gender identity, she committed to evaluating each case on merit, factual sufficiency and resource use.
Disparate impact gets pushback
Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va., challenged the agency's abandonment of disparate-impact claims (cases where a neutral policy disproportionately harms a protected group), calling them a "really important" civil rights tool. He offered a hypothetical: an employer rejecting any applicant absent more than 20 days a year — screening out women and people with disabilities.
Eschbach said those closure decisions predated her appointment, and stressed her role as litigator, not policymaker. When Kaine asked, "Do you follow the commission's directives or the law?", she answered: "I will uphold the law and the Constitution." Kaine shot back that nothing in her oath says "I will do whatever the EEOC commissioners tell me."
What about the controversial agency lawyer?
Sen. Angela Alsobrooks, D-Md., zeroed in on assistant general counsel Benjamin North, a direct report. "Are you aware that Mr. North was the subject of a Title IX investigation by his university after being credibly accused of rape by a fellow student in 2014?" she asked, noting his two-and-a-half-year suspension. Eschbach responded that North had to prove to the Virginia State Bar by "clear and convincing evidence" his good moral character and fitness to practice law. The Intercept reported North maintained his innocence and sued his college over the suspension.
Where do pregnancy protections and AI hiring stand?
Baldwin's final questions targeted the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. Eschbach noted the Justice Department, in a 5th Circuit filing, took the position the law does not cover abortion. The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is reconsidering a challenge claiming the law was invalidly passed because fewer than half of voting members were physically present, with others voting by proxy. New guidelines, Eschbach said, would come from commissioners.
Committee chair Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., raised AI hiring tools and case balance. Eschbach confirmed discrimination laws apply regardless of employers' tools, citing an EEOC settlement with an e-learning company whose recruiting algorithm allegedly screened out older applicants. "Regardless of how employers go about making their employment decisions, the antidiscrimination laws are going to apply to them," she said — the hearing's clearest bipartisan ground.
Senators' questions, spanning gender identity, disparate impact, AI and pregnancy, signal what a majority-Democratic Congress may scrutinize on compliance come January.
Source: hrdive.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.
569 articles
Go deeper
- Coca-Cola DEI case tests employers’ program design and access
- Trump Nominates Zandi to EEOC, Cementing GOP Control Until 2031
- Mid-Michigan settles $41,137 race-discrimination lawsuit
- California bans AI-only firings as 90% of US managers track workers
- California Enacts Landmark AI Workplace Laws on Termination, Layoffs