Workplace Trends

Amazon warns NYC shoppers of $5 delivery cost under council bill

Amazon says a proposed NYC delivery law could add $5 per order and disrupt a delivery network employing 5,000 people, while supporters say labor protections would strengthen accountability.

Amazon warns NYC shoppers of potential $5 per-order increase over proposed delivery law
Amazon warns NYC shoppers of potential $5 per-order increase over proposed delivery law — Sergio-sq / pixabay

By Priya Raman

Amazon is warning New York City shoppers that a proposed city law could add as much as $5 to each delivery order. The figure appears in alerts inside Amazon's shopping app.

The alerts concern Intro 518, also known as the Delivery Protection Act. They direct shoppers to Amazon's message and a form urging them to contact City Council representatives and oppose the bill. The legislation does not impose a $5 surcharge; Amazon argues that compliance costs could push prices that high.

What the bill would require

Councilwoman Tiffany Cabán, D-Queens, introduced the proposal. It would require operators of certain delivery facilities to directly employ workers who handle and deliver packages, rather than rely on third-party contractors under the proposal.

The bill would also:

  • Establish licensing requirements for companies operating covered facilities.
  • Set worker training standards.
  • Add safety protections for delivery workers.

Supporters, including Mayor Zohran Mamdani, say the measure would improve working conditions and public safety by holding major delivery companies directly accountable. The city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection endorsed the proposal, saying it would strengthen worker protections and increase accountability for labor violations. The agency also acknowledged concerns with certain provisions.

Why Amazon expects a $5 increase

Amazon says the $5 projection reflects the potential cost of complying with the legislation. The company says the requirements would force it to fundamentally restructure delivery operations in New York City, while the bill itself leaves any customer surcharge to the company rather than mandating one.

Amazon cited a study by consulting firm AKRF. That study estimates the legislation could increase annual costs for New York City households by $409 to $664. Amazon did not explain how those annual estimates translate into an increase of up to $5 per order. Its citation did not specify AKRF's sample size, estimation method or any revision history.

An Amazon spokesperson said the company wanted customers to understand what the measure would cost if it passed as written. In a customer message, the company wrote: “If this legislation passes, we'd no longer be able to work with them, and we'd be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city.” It also warns of slower deliveries, higher costs and possible job losses among delivery partners.

What does this change for workers and shoppers?

In testimony submitted earlier this year, Amazon said it works with more than 40 independent local delivery businesses employing more than 5,000 people in New York City. More than 2,000 Amazon employees work at delivery facilities across the five boroughs. The company says the bill could jeopardize its relationships with those businesses and require changes to its delivery network.

For shoppers, the practical risk is a possible $5 increase in order costs if Amazon passes through its projected compliance burden. For workers at covered facilities, the proposal would replace contractor arrangements with direct employment, licensing, training and safety duties.

Supporters see stronger accountability. Amazon sees operational disruption and potential job losses, although the available figures do not quantify those losses.

Council Speaker Julie Menin, responding in a Thursday statement, said: “It defies logic that Amazon, a $3 trillion corporation, would raise New Yorkers’ cost of living if it’s forced to adhere to basic regulations and worker protections.”

As the City Council reviews the bill, the final employment and licensing terms will determine whether Amazon's $5 estimate becomes an actual order increase or remains a company projection.

Source: moxie.foxbusiness.com

amazonnew-york-citydelivery-workersworker-protectionsgig-economy

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

606 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »