Workplace Trends

Microsoft's ex-HR VP: Workplace Romance Can Work, But It Gets Messy Fast

Microsoft's former HR VP Chris Williams, married 43 years to a work colleague, says workplace romance can work but authority makes it messy — and someone should leave.

I'm Microsoft's ex-VP of HR. Not all workplace romance is a mistake — but it can get messy quickly.
I'm Microsoft's ex-VP of HR. Not all workplace romance is a mistake — but it can get messy quickly. — Vitaly Gariev / unsplash

Jensen Huang's exit as Nvidia CEO over an alleged affair is the extreme case of a problem every HR department knows: mixing work and romance is complicated, and it gets messy quickly even with the best intentions. That's the argument from Chris Williams, former VP of HR at Microsoft, writing for Business Insider.

Williams isn't a purist on the topic. He's been happily married for 43 years to someone he met at work. "I reject the assumption that all workplace romance is a mistake," he writes. "I've seen it work well, but those are the exceptions."

Who pays the price for an office relationship?

Williams draws on a case from his own career. As a software development manager, he managed a woman whose husband was the CEO. The arrangement was set up so she wouldn't report directly to her spouse. It put Williams squarely in the middle.

He gave her a glowing performance review; she criticized his embellishment. On the next review, he was honest and direct. Her husband rebuked him and asked him to change it.

The ripple effects went beyond the reporting line. Did her colleagues refrain from criticizing her work because of who her husband was? Did her arguments in product discussions always win? People outside a relationship modify their behavior in ways large and small, Williams writes, and that impact is almost always unknown or unmeasured.

The takeaway: the damage spreads to bystanders, not just the couple.

Why the reporting line isn't the fix

Most companies prohibit relationships between a person and their direct or indirect manager. But influence spreads well beyond the chain of command, Williams argues. At the CEO level, no role sits outside the reporting line, which makes any internal affair problematic by definition.

He has seen relationships handled openly, with HR fully aware and senior leaders earnestly promising fair treatment. The relationship still has an impact. Someone involved with a senior manager wields power, even unintentionally, and can draw either a chilling effect on colleagues or unwarranted scrutiny driven by jealousy.

HR can't always get honest answers about this. People won't admit the impact, or they suspect HR isn't an objective observer, since HR works for the company. "It's a clear no-win situation," Williams writes.

The takeaway: disclosure doesn't neutralize the influence.

Can good intentions be enough?

Williams and his now-wife once worked at a company that banned all in-company dating. They were peers. They never left work together or told anyone. Yet he still recalls colleagues joking about whether her printouts came out faster because he ran the printers.

Even the most responsible leader can recuse themselves from every decision about their partner and request outside review. But they can't control how others perceive the relationship. Compensation, promotion, and performance decisions are all judgment calls, and the relationship can color them all. If the affair is extramarital, the stakes jump: morale damage, company perception, even blackmail risk. It moves from ill-advised to potentially catastrophic.

What's the cleanest solution?

One of the two people should leave for another firm, Williams says. That isn't straightforward either. Suppliers, competitors, or unrelated companies may try to leverage a spouse's influence. But at least the direct conflict is removed. And the junior person shouldn't automatically be the one to go. Often the senior person has better job prospects.

Williams's recommendation is blunt: separate work and personal lives as quickly and cleanly as possible. "Don't ask everyone else to make way for your relationship. They often can't."

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

workplace-romanceoffice-relationshipshr-policiesconflict-of-interestworkplace-ethics

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering regulation, policy and their impact on Job market data and labor economics at Path & Pay.

591 articles

Go deeper

« Previous articleNext article »